>>2235
What? I thought there were 2 Kinzo's study keys?

>>2237
Is this a logic error...?

>>2237

Wow, I am messing up on my own game. They are the exception

>>2238

I was taking a dramatic pause.

>>2235
GE could we get an exact time Shannon died. What I was doing at the time and I where I was, right when she died would be good.

I'll have to refuse that one.

>>2242
GE would it be too much trouble for you to confirm that the vase in Natsuhi and Krauss's room was the murder weapon for me?

The vase in Natsuhi and Krauss's room was the murder weapon. Beatrice used magic to levitate it.

>>2244
Shannon killed herself after locking the kitchen and painting the circle.

Shannon did not commit suicide.

As an extra, the door and window were definitely locked when the group arrived.

>>2246
What about the back door?

The back door was locked from the inside.

>>2248
Ummm. GE could I get an answer if Kinzo died in the game. I don't care for a specific time, I just want to know if he died at some point.

Kinzo survived through this game.

>>2250
Shannon was killed remotely using the drug in the syringe.

Shannon was not killed remotely by the drug. When she was killed, her killer was in the room with her.

As an extra hint: The drug is most commonly used to induce sleep.

>>2252
..............

..............

Two requests.

1. Shannon was alive when I entered the kitchen.

2. Could you describe what I would have found if I searched the parlor after Battler and Nanjo died.

I refuse the first one.

If you had searched the parlor, you would have found traces of blood, leading to the murder weapon.

>>2267
So I would have found the murder weapon?

Probably.

>>2269
Care to tell me what that was? Since I would have found it, if I would have played smart and looked.

It was a hat stand. Incidentally, Erika would have pointed out it was missing if you hadn't knocked her out.

>>2271
Nanjo killed Shannon when he was checking on her.

Correct.

"B-but that's ridiculous!" Erika said. "Nanjo died in the parlor!"

>>2273
Alright another few requests before I use so more blues.

First, I would like to know if by the time the game ended. (Which would be when we jumped to the ending right?) If all the culprits were dead. I'm not requesting you give me a number, just a yes or no answer, to "Are all the culprits dead at the end of the game?"

Second request. The 1st twilight was committed by more than one person. 1 culprit, 1 accomplice, 1 culprit and 2 accomplices, 2 culprits etc. Once again I am just requesting a general yes or no answer.

Third. I would like to know if "Culprit used the window." theory for the first twilight even holds up.

After I hear you answers I'll make my next blue.

I'll be purposely selective to what I respond to.

At the end of the game, you, Erika, and Kinzo were alive. This takes place at the battle. If the game lasted longer, the island would have been destroyed in an explosion.

As for the second, I'll refuse.


Nobody removed any windows in the guest house during the course of this game. The bodies were not carried in through windows.

>>2303
Kyrie killed at least one of the people in the first twilight.

By the way, I've decided that blues you get correct won't subtract from your count.

Kyrie killed a single person on the first twilight. You can probably guess who that person is.

>>2306
Genji or Nanjo killed the other victims of the first twilight. Or a combination of the two.

After Battler entered the detective's room, no bodies entered or left until you woke up.

This doesn't destroy your theory, but it forces you to explain.

>>2310
Battler was drugged, the culprit put him to sleep while he was waiting for Kyrie and Rudolf to show up. The text even says he dozed off.

They removed the door and entered that way.
They went upstairs and put the corpses in the room.

Battler being still drugged didn't notice the corpses when he entered the pitch black room.

The noise he heard when he went back upstairs was the sound of the door being put back on.

Your theory is correct.

Genji killed Natsuhi and Krauss and locked the door using his master key after placing the envelope.

The culprit killed Natsuhi and Krauss and locked the door using his master key after placing the envelope.

I planned on that one being harder, but things didn't go as I planned in the game. Like I said, the difficulty depended on you.

>>2322
Genji killed Nanjo and Battler with the hatstand.

Genji killed Gohda and Eva.
Nanjo killed Rosa, Hideyoshi and Genji with poison.

None of the people you mentioned died due to poison.

>>2324
Rosa and Hideyoshi were strangled to death.

Rosa and Hideyoshi were strangled to death

By whom? And how did that person die?

>>2326
Genji killed them, as to how he died... a blow to the head from before when he fought with Nanjo?

It seems that you forgot one mystery-- the fourth twilight. Yes, Kinzo was alive, but he never broke any of Eva's seals. Eva had multiple seals placed.

At the time you and Erika were fighting over whether or not battler was the culprit, all of Eva's seals were in place.

Everyone alive except for Kinzo were in the kitchen.

And yet, there was no seal on the door when you arrived. Furthermore, only human interference could remove on of Eva's seals.

fifth *

>>2328
Eva sealed the wrong room. The door to Kinzo's study was never sealed.

>>2330
^should be blue

Blues fly across the room, hitting random spots. With your last blue, the room seems to explode in a flash.

The truth that you exist is allowed to stay.

When you come to your senses, you find yourself floating in darkness. You look around, and you can see Ange floating near you.

"I...I don't understand. Nanjo doesn't seem like a bad person, and I always remember Genji being kind. He would even do extra things without asking for a reward or even a thank you. Why would they do something like this?"

>>2354
"It is most likely that Nanjo's clinc needed money, or someone he cared about was sick and needed money to be taken care of. And according to Kinzo's will he wasn't going to get any. It drove him over the edge.

Kyrie is the same, she wanted the money so she was going to kill the servants.

Genji was probably ordered by Kinzo to commit the crimes.

But that is just my guess."

"...I suppose. Money is what it all comes back to, isn't it? Still, even though that witch said she'd hand the win over to you, I wonder if she's really satisfied with this..."

---------------------

The short answer, of course, was no.

Bernkastel had banished Erika as deep into darkness as she could. She doubted that she could retrieve her if she wanted to. That thought went away quickly.

She realized her fatal flaw, of course. She had listened to others too much. If Bernkastel had just relied on herself and not bended the rules, she would most likely be the victor.

Therefore, she was creating one more idea-- a devious, cunning idea. She consulted Featherine about it earlier and had only received one message in response. " That sort of game...is only technically solvable."

It was enough. Before long, she would destroy Amy, and anyone that had helped her. She even had a name in mind: Survival of the Golden Witch.

-------------------------------------

Credits:

Ushiromiya Jessica- Died on the first twilight

Ushiromiya George- Died on the first twilight

Ushiromiya Maria- Died on the first twilight

Ushiromiya Rudolf- Died on the first twilight

Ushiromiya Kyrie- Died on the first twilight

Servant Kumasawa- Died on the first twilight

Ushiromiya Krauss- Died on the second twilight

Ushiromiya Natsuhi- Died on the second twilight

Servant Shannon- Died on the fourth twilight

Ushiromiya Battler- Died on the sixth twilight.

Nanjo- Died on the seventh twilight

Servant Genji- Died on the eighth twilight.

Ushiromiya Rosa- Died on the eighth twilight.

Ushiromiya Hideyoshi- Died on the eighth twilight.

Servant Gohda- Died on the eighth twilight.

Ushiromiya Kinzo- Alive.

Furudo Erika- Alive.

Furudo Amy- Alive (?)

The winners of this game are Ushiromiya Kinzo, Furudo Erika, and Furudo Amy. They managed to stay alive, so the witch was impressed enough to let them live. In the end, it is the winners whow rite the history books.

END.

To be continued in Antithesis of the Golden Witch.

Ushiromiya Eva- Died on the eighth twilight

>>2356
Yeah I had a blast. It was a ton of fun. Sorry about the giving up though. I think the part where you said. "You did not find all the clues and stuff." Kind of messed me up, and I partly stopped thinking and then when we were talking and created the Kinzo theory, I just accepted it. Despite that I should have seen it doesn't work.

I apologize for that. I should have played better. Nonetheless I had a blast playing and solving it at the end.

I hope you enjoyed it as well.

congratulations rosa