/theories and interpretations/

File 140099710589.jpg - (147.79KB , 850x794 , sample-158cafd32b8091350be168daf729.jpg )

Goatman 14/05/25(Sun)05:51:45 No. 211

So in the very end, who was the person Battler loved all along?

Yasu, or Beatrice?

>>	Goatman 14/05/26(Mon)14:08:17 No. 212 Both. He loves Beatrice before he discovers the truth about her and after.

>>	Goatman 14/05/27(Tue)00:11:17 No. 213 File 140114947764.jpg - (485.21KB , 868x1300 , img000023.jpg )

>>	Renall 14/06/07(Sat)06:10:05 No. 214 >>211 Which Battler?

E.F. Darrow 14/09/17(Wed)02:50:28 No. 215

Both, because I refuse to accept Ryukishi's argument that a person's body can't be held accountable for the actions of the mind inhabiting it. That's called the insanity defense.
Because Yasu loved everybody, I affectionately refer to Umineko as the Sayo Yasuda Dating Game.

Goatman 14/11/28(Fri)03:18:13 No. 220

>Battler doesn't give two shits about Sayo in the past.
>Beatrice is his ideal woman.
>Scenes in Chiru show him talking to Beatrice and he doesn't mention Shkannon or whatever at all.

I think Sayo pretty much had no choice but to 'become' Beatrice in order for Battler to love her, it was said in Episode 7. Battler actually never loved Sayo herself.

Name
Email
Subject	(reply to 211)
Message
Captcha
Tags
File
Password	(for post and file edit/deletion)

Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG Maximum file size allowed is 2097152 KB. Images greater than 200x200 pixels will be thumbnailed. Currently 89 unique user posts. View catalog Blotter updated: 2014-04-26 Show/Hide Show All 04/26/14 - After years of mystery, "Something went wrong (blank response)" errors should not occur any more. 05/14/13 - The edit button has been updated. It now can retrieve long posts from outside threads, and will properly copy formatting tags. 04/16/13 - User editing can now be used to edit images in posts. 04/14/13 - See this list for the colors available. Any hex RGB color is supported, but make sure to use a hash. Example: [color=#00FFFF]text[/color]