>>
|
No. 5098
>>5093
IN THE END, NOT SURE, NE. Either 1, 3, or 5, ne.
1. Beatrice
Maybe, ne. Since it could be interpreted as one person or ONLY one person, ne. Confusing. Ne. If Genji is telling the truth, then, he should be saying that Battler is a liar, ne. But then it says that Kanon is telling the truth, whereas Kanon is saying that Genji is lying as well, so, fake, ne. Kanon has the possibility as telling the truth too, ne! If Beatrice means, "there is one person but there are also more that are telling the truth," then, this possibility can be true, ne.
(Kanon), (Beatrice), Kinzo, Genji, Battler
2. Beatrice & Genji
No, ne. Same reason as above, ne. Battler already lies, ne. So, crossing out Battler, there is Beatrice and Kanon, who can be said as telling the truth, ne. But then, Kanon says that Genji lies, so, can't be, ne.
Kanon???, (Beatrice), Kinzo, (Genji), Battler
3. Beatrice and Kanon
Maybe, ne. If Kanon is telling the truth, then, Genji and Battler are crossed out. Then, since Beatrice is telling the truth, Kinzo should be crossed out too. So, maybe, ne.
(Kanon), (Beatrice), Kinzo, Genji, Battler
4. Genji and Kinzo
No, ne. If Kinzo is telling the truth, then, Beatrice is crossed out. Then, if Genji is telling the truth, then, Beatrice is lying, and Battler and Kanon are telling the truth. But then, Kanon says that Genji is a liar, so, no, ne.
Kanon, Beatrice, (Kinzo), (Genji), Battler
5. Kanon and Kinzo
Maybe, ne. If Kinzo is telling the truth, Beatrice is crossed out. Then, if Kanon is telling the truth, Genji and Battler are crossed out, ne. It's possible, ne.
(Kanon), Beatrice, (Kinzo), Genji, Battler
6. Battler
JOHN SMITH ALREADY SAID THIS WAS A LIE, NE.
|