|
>>
|
No. 12227
Well, here's most of the reds so far, I'm doing this since I was requested to, and it'll help both the players and the lurkers who feel lost with so much red and blue to keep track of. There may be some missing though.
General Red
Kanon and Shannon are not the same person.
The safe contained the infamous ten tons of gold of Kinzo, Genji was aware of this, knew how to access the secret basement and how to open the safe. Had he wanted money, he could have very well stole it.
The numbered keys can only open their own room. No numbered key can open another bedroom than their own.
When the group entered the secret basement, the safe was already open. Hideyoshi did turn the key, however nothing happened.
The term you're looking for is ventriloquism. No one on the island is able to do such a thing.
The only ways to enter room 01 is by the door or the several windows.
No material were brought or existed on the island that could fake someone's death or create a fake corpse real enough that no one would notice it.
There is only one person to bear the name Krauss.
No lock on the island was picked on.
Any numbered/old key can perfectly open the dining room, among others.
it's impossible to lock something by slamming or kicking it.
The doors can only be locked while they are closed.
No autolock exists on any door in the whole guesthouse.
The number of keys never changed during the whole game
No secret passage except the one to the secret basement ever existed during the whole course of the game.
No hole existed at any point either.
It is possible to close the window from the outside, however it can only be locked from the inside
No such mechanism were brought or existed on the island
It is impossible to axe someone through the keyhole.
No hole were dug inside the guesthouse.
No doors or walls were removed.
The ceiling did not budge.
What Maria saw was the entrance to the Secret passage.
Jessica and Natsuhi's hand were never cut off from their respective bodies.
There exist no person that have the same name as another on the island.
No revolving walls exist.
Everyone was handed the correct keys.
The clock's time is correct and was never tampered with at any moment.
The only keys on the island are the three master keys, the 4 numbered keys, the 7 regular keys, the storehouse key and Genji's briefcase key. No other key ever existed at any point on the island.
The keys that open the safe are the 4 numbered keys.
The rooms cannot move around. The rooms refer to the room themselves, and never did they change location.
No mechanism were used for the whole game to create closed rooms or to murder apart from Genji's
Rooms names only refer to a single room.
Krauss's key was found whole and stayed that way for the whole game. Natsuhi's key stayed whole too.
No one swapped their names with anyone.
First Paradox
The string wasn't used to slide the key under the door
The key wasn't slid into the room
The shelf fell after the window had been shut and locked.
The window was not closed and locked by a human hand, but by a mechanism
That is mostly correct. There was no weight however, Genji's head acted as the weight, and the string was not broken by a gunshot, but by the shelf falling over.
The door of the storehouse cannot be locked from the inside, be it with a key or without.
The culprit never handed the key to someone else. Nor was it handed to him.
The key couldn't have returned in his pocket simply by throwing it from the window, and the string was not used that way.
The key was already in Genji's pocket before the group entered and discovered his body.
The window was unlocked from the start.
Genji did enter from the window with the key still inside of his pocket.
Genji did not lock the door.
The culprit never entered the room via the window.
Correct. The storehouse was locked from the start, Genji entered by the window and set everything up, then the culprit shot him.
Genji wasn't aware that objects were missing when he took the key.
On the schedule, no preparations were to be made before 3:00 AM, yet Genji took the key around 0:30 AM.
Genji never considered the possibility of objects being missing in the storehouse.
Genji was not aware he was going to die.
Genji believed he would use the key to enter the storehouse when he took it.
Genji's getting old, sure, but be it an hurry or not, he would have still found the key if it were in his pocket.
Genji would never give in to physical threat.
Genji did not have any knowledge about weaponry apart from tools like the axe or knives that could be used as murder weapons, and that much almost everyone knew or could have guessed.
Genji never retrieved any of the objects found later on the crime scenes
Genji was instructed to do so. However, he would have never obeyed such an order under normal conditions.
No "heir authority" was used to make Genji comply.
Genji is a man of honor
The only will Genji ever followed was Kinzo's, him being tied up and his death were not part of it.
No such material exists.
Genji did not go to the storehouse on a bet.
Genji's death was caused on purpose.
Two keys were found on Genji's body : The storehouse key and his own master key, that Kanon took.
Genji was not in love with anyone !
The storehouse door was perfectly functional.
Genji didn't think he'd be rescued by anyone in particular. He just didn't expect to be killed, and honor had nothing to do with that.
The culprit never threatened to kill any family member that night.
Genji's motive is not related to money.
The culprit didn't threaten to hurt any family member either.
The culprit didn't threaten to kill the servants.
The culprit didn't have multiple personalities.
Genji was very much dead when he was found on the morning of the second day.
When Genji handed the keys to everyone not a word of his concerning what they were and what they opened was false.
Second Paradox
Krauss was not killed after the closed room had been broken
When Kanon went to see Krauss, he only knocked and left as Krauss started shouting to be left alone.
Kanon did not mistake what he heard, what Krauss said was perfectly intelligible.
Well the keys that can open the room are all clear right ? : The numbered key, the two small keys given to Natsuhi and Jessica and the master keys. No more key exist that can open this door
No recorders were brought on the island by anybody.
Krauss was not dying when he told Kanon to go away.
When the corpse was discovered, no one was hiding in room 01
Krauss was alive when Kanon knocked on the door at 10:20 a.m.
Kanon's master key was not used to lock or open the door during this murder.
Krauss was already dead when Natsuhi left the parlor.
No master key was used to lock that door.
No string trick was used to get the key back in Krauss's room.
Natsuhi and Jessica's never handed their regular keys, never lost and were never stolen of it before the corpse was discovered.
The 12 people alive at the time were present inside the room at the discovery of Krauss's corpse. And everyone acknowledged the presence of those 12 persons alive plus Krauss's corpse.
The key found inside Krauss's pocket was marked with the number I in roman numbers, it is unmistakable and none other like it exist.
The corpse I am referring to is Krauss's corpse.
The key was already there when Natsuhi entered.
Krauss died instantly.
Jessica's key was not used to lock or open that door from the point Jessica got into the parlor with the others up to the discovery of Krauss's corpse.
After Natsuhi got into the parlor, she never left it until she went to check up on Krauss
Krauss's death was a homicide
Rosa was successful in getting Maria to come with her, Jessica is then included in the "three children".
Jessica did not leave the parlor after 10:20 AM until Krauss's corpse was found.
When Natsuhi left to notify her husband, the door was locked.
Krauss died of a severe case of axe to the face.
No trap was used to kill Krauss
The key was already in Krauss's pocket when Natsuhi left the parlor.
The window was never broken
The door can only be locked/unlocked from the inside or by a key
No string trick was used to lock the door.
The culprit was inside of the room when Krauss died.
Jessica was in the parlor before 10:20 AM.
Krauss was killed in room 01.
The windows were already closed and locked when Natsuhi opened the door.
From 8:00 AM, when Jessica entered the parlor to 11:30 AM, the discovery of Krauss's corpse, Jessica's key was not used to open or lock the door to room 01.
No living person was inside of the room at the time Natsuhi opened the door.
Natsuhi opening the door and the discovery of Krauss's corpse are considered the same event.
Krauss only died once.
The lock was not removed.
No other corpses than Krauss's were inside the room when Natsuhi opened the door.
The door was locked with a key.
Krauss's pocket refers to the pocket of his pants, and no article of clothing of his was missing
Everyone entered room 01 upon discovery.
Apart from when the door and the windows, there exist no space big enough for anyone to enter in the room.
From the moment they were given their key by Genji until the discovery of Krauss's corpse, Jessica and Natsuhi's key never left their possession.
The key was inside the pocket of the pants that his corpse is wearing
No hole big enough to let the key go through exists either.
Natsuhi only went to check up on Krauss once.
Natsuhi's key never left her possession from 9h15 until the discovery of Krauss's corpse.
The culprit had left by the time Natsuhi got out of the parlor.
No part of the room was removed or destroyed.
It is impossible to lock the window from the outside.
The corpse was found intact except for the wound in the head.
Third Paradox : SOLVED
The culprit never moved Eva's body after she died.
The three master keys were put on a table in the servant's room by Kanon and Shannon before they went to sleep that night, they found it at the same place next morning.
Eva was not bound nor gagged.
Eva did not expect anyone to save her.
The fire extinguisher was there to begin with.
The servant's room was locked at the time of the 3rd murder.
Nor Kanon nor Shannon gave any of their keys before Natsuhi took them the next day.
Kanon and Shannon never stepped inside the kitchen after their supposed hour of sleep until they woke up the next day.
The only other corpses existing on the island at that time were Genji's and Krauss's. And both were in the storehouse when this one was discovered.
The fire extinguisher is working perfectly.
Her life was her priority.
The window of the kitchen is too small for someone adult-sized ( Everyone except Maria ) to enter or exit the room.
Eva died from immolation. The fire extinguisher was in plain view for her when she was set on fire.
No trace of fire was found in the room beside Eva. Basically even though half of the kitchen was burnt, it's only concentrated around Eva's corpse.
The fire extinguisher was perfectly reachable.
Correct, the culprit set Eva on fire from the outside.
The culprit was not holding the fire extinguisher, in fact Eva could access it easily.
Eva was never told or instructed anything about the fire extinguisher.
Eva was not in such pain she could not use it.
Eva did not attack the culprit with the fire extinguisher
Since when were you under the impression that Eva did not reach the fire extinguisher ?
Because she did, she even managed to take it and was holding it.
Eva was holding the fire extinguisher while she was on fire.
Eva did not lose consciousness.
The fire extinguisher contained gas.
The culprit did not lit on fire the room itself.
The fire was started by the culprit.
The wielding torch was not used to light Eva on fire.
Fourth Paradox
Rudolf is very much dead.
Rudolf died within 20 seconds after he had been given the final blow, however he did not lock or close anything.
Rudolf was the one to set the chain.
Rudolf was killed through the opening formed by the chain lock.
Rosa had the three master keys, but the master keys were not used to lock room 1.
Natsuhi and Jessica had the numbered key and both their regular keys but they never out of sight from the group. And they were never seen opening that door until Rudolf's corpse was discovered.
They both woke up upon hearing Shannon's scream, and they didn't found any corpse upon waking up.
They were never seen locking the door either.
Rudolf was alive when they entered the kitchen.
Due to how the group was, there was nothing they could do covertly
Rudolf was not stabbed before they entered the kitchen.
A key was used to lock the door.
The scene in the kitchen was genuine for at least 5 out of the 6 persons.
Natsuhi and Jessica's key never left their respective persons.
Fifth Paradox
Had a chair been placed to block the door, they would have found it when entering, however all the chair in the room were in order and far away from the door.
They'd have found the culprit inside of the room had he done such a thing.
Natsuhi did not lie.
That key did not change hands since Natsuhi picked up.
Same thing as the chair or the culprit blocking the door, they'd have found the key afterward.
The lock was not busted by the culprit.
|
