[Burichan]  [Futaba]  [Nitronet]  [nitroib4f]  - 
Theories here.

[Return]
Posting Mode: Read-Only
Name
Email
Subject   (reply to 2)
Comment
Tags

File
Password  (for post and file edit/deletion) Edit post id:
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 1000 KB.
  • Images greater than 200x200 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Currently 9 unique user posts. View catalog

  • Blotter updated: 2014-04-26 Show/Hide Show All

File 129700426875.png - (142.80KB , 300x299 , Aikousha_Ep1_Teaparty.png )
2 No. 2
[Cathedral of Witches]

In a flash the calm little party disappeared and instead the cold ghastly cathedral replaced it. Beatrice and Battler looked around confused, for they were alone.

A bright flash blinded them before they could shield their eyes. When their vision cleared now standing in the area were 3 more people. Bernkastel the Witch of Miracles, Lambdadelta the Witch of Certainty, and Erika the Witch of Truth.

Erika let out a horrible laugh. “Come, let's see you try to beat the truth; that I Erika Furudo the Witch of Truth am about the create!”

Bernkastel let out a sinister cackle as she teleported next to the two. “Come now, we'll make it fair even.” A crafty cat like smile appeared on her face. “We'll give you five chances, that is more than fair right~”

The three witches became laughing in sync with each other. Lamdadelta smirked, as she stopped laughing. “Come show us what you got.”

“Yes, let us battle. The Witch of Truth vs you!”
Expand all images
>> No. 6
File 129700804421.png - (263.93KB , 576x480 , er2_akuwaraib3.png )
6
"And just in case you aren't sure how this works. You must present a full theory, one that presents an answer for each and every mystery presented inside the tale."
>> No. 36
File 129704932192.png - (427.37KB , 576x558 , ros2_waraia1 (1) copy.png )
36
Oh I should mention that I'm not requesting an answer for the following things.

Rose Garden Scene
Jessica's disappearance
Shannon Bathroom
Natsuhi and Krauss's body vanishing.
the letter appearing.
Maria's Letter
and the Strange note.
>> No. 46
File 129730722920.jpg - (22.97KB , 261x400 , 2009-09-15-198759.jpg )
46
I'll give it our first shot. I'm confident enough.

The culprit is Ushiromiya Jessica! Not only that, but she had an accomplice...Kanon!

The real victim of the first twilight was not Kanon, but actually Shannon! Kanon then dressed up as Shannon for the remained of the game. He may or may have not told her about this.

This way, all red truths about Shannon mean absolutely nothing!

First Twilight: Jessica kills Krauss and Natsuhi, and Kanon kills the rest of the victims to protect Jessica. He wants to make it seem like the witch is doing it! He even makes the bodies disappear. He is still dressed up as Shannon, so he has the perfect means.

Second Twilight: Jessica kills Hideyoshi, then Kanon makes his body disappear. It's possible that Kanon saved Jessica from Eva as well, and Jessica thought she saw Shannon! Kanon also his this body.

Fourth twilight: Kinzo died before the game began.

Fifth Twilight: Kanon/Jessica kills Kyrie. Uses a rose or something to mess with the locks. Alternatively, a rock.

Sixth: Hid Erika on order to protect her. Faked his own death using medical knowledge. Nanjo wouldn't go out without a fight.

Maria: Killed by Jessica/Kanon, who snuck out.

Battler: Same as Maria.

Last Mystery: Everyone except for Erika died in an accident. Or, she really did kill them!

Check!




>> No. 47
File 12973077392.png - (89.88KB , 343x440 , ber_defa2.png )
47
Before I answer I request a why.

"What was the motive?"
>> No. 48
Clearly, Jessica hated the family that only saw her as the future head. She had no intention of being with this family, and wanted to start a new life with Kanon. However, her mother and father would not allow this, so Jessica killed them. When Kanon saw what she had done, he knew that he had no choice but to help. Afterwards, Jessica continued, deciding to save George's relationship by killing Eva and Hideyoshi, unaware that Kanon was alive and that Shannon was dead.

In an odd way, it really is a story of love.
>> No. 49
File 129730824695.png - (89.93KB , 343x440 , ber_defa1.png )
49
"Interesting."
>> No. 50
File 129730842344.png - (115.72KB , 200x450 , Dlanor2.png )
50
Either you're stunned speechless, or I'm about to get trolled...
>> No. 51
File 129700804421.png - (263.93KB , 576x480 , er2_akuwaraib3.png )
51
"What? Is that all you've got? Taste my scythe.
Ushiromiya Jessica is not the mastermind.

Kanon never pretended to be Shannon.

Kinzo was alive at the start of this game.

Neither a rose or a rock was used to create the closed room in the boiler room.

No one on Rokkenjima died by accident.


This shatters your theory to pieces."
>> No. 52
File 129701535880.jpg - (120.62KB , 771x703 , Haspien-on-03-01-10-at-10-13-34.jpg )
52
Hold it!

Maybe Jessica wasn't the mastermind, but you never said she didn't kill anyone! Deny it! Deny my motive! You can't, can you?
>> No. 53
File 129704968655.png - (147.23KB , 349x480 , lam_akuwaraia3.png )
53
"Well~ If you really want me to~ While her mother and father wouldn't allow her to be with Kanon. Jessica wouldn't kill them because of that."
>> No. 55
Erg...

And what about Kanon? Can you honestly say that he didn't kill for Jessica?
>> No. 56
File 129731026439.png - (146.79KB , 349x480 , lam_akuwaraia1.png )
56
"Yes I can~ Kanon didn't kill anyone so he could be with Jessica.
>> No. 58
File 12974981258.jpg - (8.88KB , 188x268 , [email protected] )
58
I just want to let all 3 of you know that I've decided to inforce the 5 guesses. You have 4 more guesses.
>> No. 59
>>58
It was more like inform one of us. Since me and Kinjo were in the stream, but ok.
>> No. 60
File 129766365279.png - (161.29KB , 434x480 , wdk_ikaria1.png )
60
>>51
Define "mastermind".
>> No. 62
>>60
The person who does the most if not all the killings.
>> No. 63
File 129778333944.jpg - (10.65KB , 234x251 , dr_ozaki tried_smoke tea.jpg )
63
Hmm ok, I've got motivation now. I'll jot down some notes on the twilights then try and make a full theory tonight.
>> No. 64
File 129811588292.png - (153.54KB , 606x480 , wdk_akuwaraib1.png )
64
Okay, here I go! The second theory!

Kanon is the culprit. His master key is not immediately found, so it could have been used for the closed room tricks. Also, he is the only person other than Shannon who could have placed all the corpses in their spots between midnight and 6AM. Kanon was forced by Kinzo to kill his family, and those six were the best sacrifices to choose, in his opinion. If he killed her parents they could be together. And he killed the rest of the servants because to him, they were furniture, mere sacrifices. Kanon killed them, tore off their skin using acid (or alternatively the stove), put their keys in the bags, and locked the room with his master key. He then went to the chapel and faked his death. George and Shannon found him and agreed to keep it a secret. Because Kanon was assumed dead, the following can be said in red: Shannon was the only living person that went outside between midnight and 6AM. Because Kanon is 'dead'.

Jessica is the culprit of the second twilight. She simply lied about seeing Shannon kill them. Jessica thought Eva was the killer since she always hated Krauss, Natsuhi, and the servants. Of course since Kanon is still alive the two of them teamed up and killed Eva together. Hideyoshi tried to stop them but also died. Jessica blamed it on Shannon, while Kanon once again went into hiding. Kanon used his signature cleaver to chop up Hideyoshi, and used a hammer from the toolbox to smash Eva.

Now, here's where things get confusing. Kinzo is still alive. Instead, Kanon put Nanjo's corpse in the boiler! When Erika and Nanjo left, they found Kanon. Erika made Kanon confess everything, and told her Kinzo was the culprit. Nanjo used an anesthetic to knock Erika out. However, Kanon killed Nanjo and burnt his corpse, using another entrance to the room. The door was hammered in place so that it wouldn't budge.

Kyrie goes into the boiler room, and gets killed by Kinzo, who tries to frame Rosa by writing 'rose' in Kanji.

However, when Kinzo got back to the guesthouse, Kanon was there waiting for him. He killed Kinzo, smashed his head, and made it look like Nanjo's corpse.

Battler and Maria interpreted the Kanji message to be 'go to the rose garden'. So they did. But Jessica killed them, to help out Kanon.

Even though Erika knew the truth, no one believed it. Instead, thinking Erika had no alibi, they all condemned her as the culprit. Rosa, furious, shot Erika. They all shot each other in turn, and the last committed suicide.

When the seagulls cry, there are no survivors.
>> No. 66
File 129811669092.png - (91.89KB , 343x440 , ber_akuwaraia3.png )
66
>>64
Kanon is not the mastermind.

Acid was not used on the victims of the 1st twilight.

Jessica is only saying what she believes happened in the dinning room.

Nanjo's body wasn't placed in the boiler.

Kinzo did not commit murder.

Erika was not killed by Rosa

No one died of suicide.

This is correct When the seagulls cry, were no survivors.



Delete post []
Password  
Report post
Reason